Can a Notary Decline to Notarize?

Already a notary? Our self-paced online courses help you expand your services and grow your income. Browse courses →

Yes. A notary can refuse to notarize, and in many situations, refusing is not just allowed but legally required. Your commission gives you the authority to perform notarial acts, but it also comes with the obligation to decline when something is wrong.

The hard part is telling the difference between a situation where you must refuse and one where you have a choice. This guide covers both.

When You Must Refuse

These are non-negotiable. If any of these conditions apply, you cannot proceed with the notarization regardless of how much the signer insists.

The signer is not physically present

Every state requires the signer to appear before the notary at the time of notarization. No exceptions for phone calls, video chats (unless performing RON under specific state authorization), or someone claiming to have power of attorney over the signer. If the person whose signature you are notarizing is not sitting in front of you, you cannot proceed.

The signer cannot produce acceptable identification

You must verify the signer’s identity using state-approved ID. If the signer has no government-issued photo ID, no credible witnesses available, or presents an expired ID that your state does not accept, you must decline. The exception: some states allow credible witnesses to vouch for a signer’s identity when no ID is available. California allows one or two credible witnesses depending on the circumstances.

The document is incomplete

Documents with blank spaces that should contain information create an opening for fraud. California, Colorado, Florida, and several other states specifically prohibit notarizing incomplete documents. If a form has blank lines, ask the signer to fill them in, cross them out, or write “N/A” before you proceed.

You have a financial or beneficial interest

If you stand to gain from the transaction being notarized, you cannot serve as an impartial witness. Being named in the document as a grantee, beneficiary, or party to the deal disqualifies you. This applies even if the benefit is indirect. Kansas takes this further than most states, prohibiting notarization when either the notary or the notary’s spouse is a party to the record.

The signer appears coerced or unwilling

One of your core duties is confirming that the signer is acting voluntarily. If someone is pressuring the signer, telling them what to sign, or the signer appears afraid, stop. You cannot notarize a signature that was obtained under duress.

The signer lacks mental capacity

If the signer has been adjudicated mentally incapacitated and has not been restored to capacity, you cannot notarize their signature. You can also decline if the signer appears disoriented, confused, or unaware of what they are signing, even without a formal adjudication. This comes up frequently in hospital and nursing home settings.

When You Have Discretion to Refuse

These situations are judgment calls. You will not necessarily violate the law by proceeding, but you may choose to decline for your own protection.

The signer cannot tell you what notarial act is needed

If the document has no notarial certificate and the signer does not know whether they need an acknowledgment, jurat, or something else, you are in a gray area. You cannot choose the notarial act for the signer, because that could constitute the unauthorized practice of law. What you can do is describe the different acts and let the signer choose. If the signer still cannot decide and cannot contact the issuing agency, you should decline.

The signer appears intoxicated or impaired

There is no law that says you cannot notarize for someone who has been drinking. But if the person appears too impaired to understand what they are signing, their willingness and awareness are in question. Err on the side of caution.

You suspect fraud

If something about the transaction feels wrong, trust your instincts. A signer who is nervous, a document that has been altered with white-out, a third party who keeps answering questions for the signer, or an ID that looks suspicious are all valid reasons to decline. You do not need proof of fraud to refuse. A reasonable suspicion is enough.

The request is outside your comfort zone

If you are not sure how to handle a particular notarization, declining is better than guessing. Notarizing incorrectly exposes you to liability. Tell the signer you are not able to help with this specific request and suggest they find another notary or consult an attorney.

When You Cannot Refuse

There are limits on when you can say no. You should not refuse a notarization simply because you disagree with the document’s contents or because the signer is from a particular background, religion, or political group. If the notarization request is lawful, the signer is present, has proper ID, and is acting willingly, you generally should proceed.

Some states have anti-discrimination provisions in their notary statutes. Refusing service based on race, religion, national origin, or other protected characteristics can result in disciplinary action against your commission.

How to Handle the Refusal Professionally

When you decline a notarization, keep it simple and neutral. You do not need to accuse anyone of fraud or make a scene. A straightforward explanation works best.

Some examples:

• “I am not able to notarize this document because your ID has expired. You will need a current, government-issued photo ID.”
• “The blank spaces on this form need to be completed before I can notarize it. You can fill them in or write ‘N/A’ where appropriate.”
• “I am not able to determine what type of notarization this document requires. You may want to contact the agency that issued it and ask what type of notarial act they need.”

Document the refusal in your notary journal. Note the date, the signer’s name (if known), the type of document, and the reason you declined. This protects you if the signer later claims you refused without cause.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer force me to notarize something I think is improper?

No. Your obligation to follow notary law overrides your employer’s instructions. If your boss tells you to notarize a document that violates state rules (missing ID, signer not present, conflict of interest), you must refuse. Explain the legal issue. Your commission is in your name, not your employer’s, and you bear the consequences of improper notarizations.

Can I refuse to notarize for a family member?

You can, but the rules vary. Some states, like Florida, specifically prohibit notarizing for a spouse, parent, or child. Most states allow it as long as you have no financial interest in the transaction. If you are uncomfortable notarizing for a relative, you are free to decline and refer them to another notary.

What if the signer gets angry when I refuse?

Stay calm and professional. Restate the reason for your refusal clearly. If the signer becomes threatening or aggressive, end the interaction. You are under no obligation to continue a conversation that has become hostile. If you feel unsafe, contact local law enforcement.

Do I have to give a reason for refusing?

You are not legally required to explain your refusal in most states, but providing a brief reason is good practice. It helps the signer understand what they need to fix, and it documents your professional conduct. If the issue is fixable (expired ID, blank spaces), telling the signer gives them a chance to correct it.

Can I refuse to notarize a document written in a language I do not understand?

Yes. If you cannot read the document well enough to confirm it is complete and to identify the notarial certificate, you can decline. Some states require the notary to be able to communicate directly with the signer without a translator. Arizona, for example, requires that the notary and signer share a common language.

NotaryTrainingSchool.com provides training on handling difficult notarization situations and protecting your commission.